The “No Gaijin Allowed” mentality

Now that I’m back from Hawaii, I finally had the chance to wade through all the emails I decided to ignore until now (sorry if that was you!). A decent number of them were people worried about racism in Japan; mainly, they were worried that people in Japan would treat them poorly because they were, well, gaijin (that means foreigner, in case you didn’t know).

A few of these emails made reference to the infamous “no gaijin” signs which are supposedly littered all around Japan. When I searched around the internet for more information on this, I was surprised with what I found…

Well, actually, not that surprised.

First off, it’s not that bad. In fact, it’s the opposite. There is so much talk going around the gaijin world about anti-gaijin sentiment, or the “no gaijin allowed” signs…thankfully, a lot of this talk is done by people who don’t know much about Japan, or have never been there. A few rumors have spread around, they’ve gotten bigger, and people pass the word on until it becomes a bigger monster.

Now, I’m not saying that racism isn’t a problem in Japan. In fact, where isn’t it an issue? As a gaijin, you will stand out, and in a country that is 99% Japanese, you will be interesting and people will be interested. Does that mean people will treat you poorly? No, not necessarily. Will you get a lot more attention than if you were Japanese? Definitely.

I found a couple vides via JapanProbe the other day. I thought they were absolutely hilarious, though it seems as though JapanProbe’s commentors thought it was pretty insensitive and mean. I can’t help it, though, I’m a Dave Chappelle fan.

[yframe url='http://youtube.com/watch?v=VGaKYtI_flI']

And commercial #2

[yframe url='http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owLnfQQ3heI']

This sort of moves me into my next topic: “No Gaijin Allowed” signs.

If you search for “No Gaijin Allowed” in Google, you’d probably expect to come up with a bunch of hits. If you search for it in an image search, maybe you’d expect tons of “no gaijin” signs chained onto restaurant doors (so that those dirty gaijin can’t rip them off and steal them). Instead, I found almost nothing. My normal Google search consisted of “No Gaijin Allowed” tshirts, and the image search came up with things that had nothing to do with anything. I wasn’t too shocked, though, I did expect to see more.

The reason for this? Those signs aren’t really that prevalent. I’ve been all over Japan, and I try to go to as many different places as I can. I have not once seen a sign like this. When reading about people’s experiences who have seen these signs, they explain that these signs don’t necessarily mean “No Gaijin Allowed.” Instead, they mean “We don’t want any trouble from Gaijin, so be respectful” or “We can’t speak English, and we don’t want to be bothered with body communication.”

Still, there is some anti-gaijin sentiment. I’m not denying that. Gaijin don’t always make a good name for themselves, and the few bad apples ruin it for everyone. Since gaijin stand out so much in Japan, one misbehaving gaijin can make all gaijin look bad. Every once in a while a story like this will come out. On top of this, there is some bad blood between the older generation that fought in the war and anyone not Japanese. Even that is turning around though, and I’ve never had a bad experience with someone of the older generation. Still, I can see some potential problem. On the other hand, our War veterans sometimes have bad feelings about Japanese, so it’s not like it’s any different.

Anyways, I just wanted to say that the “anti-gaijin” mentality isn’t as prevalent as a lot of people think. Japan’s a friendly place, and as long as you try to keep in mind that you are in another country, and you need to follow some of their cultural guidelines (like taking off your shoes, damnit!), you shouldn’t have any trouble. If you don’t make an effort, though, and think that you can get away with anything…well…then you might get some anti-gaijin sentiment. I warned you, though.

So what about you? Have you ever had any experience with this?

[Image source]

  • http://youtube.com/profile?user=chokudori クリス

    Full of homeless and ice-up locals, but I wouldn’t consider them crazy… unless you drive down Merchant and Hotel street, haha.

  • http://youtube.com/profile?user=chokudori クリス

    Well at least you were mistaken for Japanese, which I think is pretty cool [I'm probably only saying this because I'm really into Japanese culture] I’m Filipino, but apparently I give off the impression that I’m Hispanic [No offense to anyone Hispanic]. I was with a customer and she was ordering in Spanish, now my Spanish isn’t good, but what led her on to believe I was really Hispanic was that I understood what she said and replied back in the same language, which just made it worse on me. Blah blah woof woof… maybe my eyes just don’t look right.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/CHESTERlikesSUBARU Chester_King

    Hmmmm…..

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NHyUHnjjCGo&feat

    Not as impressive as world history has taught us………..

    oh, well…..

  • http://youtube.com/profile?user=chokudori クリス

    I can relate, but then again my family in Hawaii are so out of touch with technology, I wouldn’t be able to get onto the net if I wanted. I think the most modern thing they use is a karaoke machine and cell phones.

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    lol

  • http://youtube.com/profile?user=chokudori クリス

    I wonder if that spray comes in different scents。 納豆 might be a good scent to drive away those 外人。

    ”外人がありません?”
    ”え〜そなのかんけね!”

  • yza

    Awigatou Koichi!

  • yza

    Etou…. XD LOLzzzzz

    Hontoni Omoshiroi – the commercial.

    XD LOLzz

    Thankiez so much again Koichi!

    mata

  • yza

    Gomenasai! I mean the video not the commercial. But if it is a real commercial then it is. ahehe

    Still, Gomen.

  • Zaywex

    Actually, I have. -_=;; However, I think that was just one woman.
    A cousin and I were traveling via 新幹線 (is that the right kanji?) and we were sitting next to a middle aged woman. She started up a conversation w/ my cousin (who is half 日本人) and eventually she asked about me. So I turned around and introduced myself (you know, よろしくおねがいします, etc) but she sort of ignored me….
    So I spent the rest of the trip looking out the window. ;_;
    Maybe I had a really weird accent…?

  • レイさん

    Haha Awesome Sign

  • http://Wafukari.intothenew.net Wafukari

    That is mainly because us Americans will sue for anything. Besides getting sued by everyone and their mother, in America, those signs are against the law, AND this doesn’t really stop those signs from being put up. I have seen my fair share of anti black and Asian signs all over the states. I disagree with these signs and usually will refuse service to places that have them, but they still exist. I, also, don’t think that people are saying that “because everyone else does it, then Japan is too”. I think they mean don’t give more criticism to Japan for having those signs when there are plenty of places in the world that do the same if not worse.

    My opinion is slightly skewed. I have never been to Japan, though I will be moving there in a months time, but I will get to see first hand what it is like. I will be living in Saitama and will probably visit Tokyo very frequently.

    Just a few things I wanted to say. I don’t mean to cause an argument. So please lets not escalate this to an argument. Not saying you were going to, just wanted to say it before it happened. Okay, I’m talking too much now.

    See you guys

  • St

    Yes that’s right, 新幹線: new trunk line. Which is of course far more convenient than the 古枝弯.

  • kevinnwhat

    those videos are hilarious hhaha

  • wei wei

    wow ok thanks that really clears the air about that in japan

  • http://google.com Allison

    Racism happens, whether there is a sign or not. A couple I know live in downtown Nagoya and tried to go to a restaurant within walking distance of their apartment. They were greeted with a Japanese woman crossing her arms, giving them the universal sign for no entry. And on the train, the seat beside you is the last seat to fill up, if they even choose to sit beside you. One time I entered onto a train, two high school girls looked at me, looked at each other then walked out of the train to enter another car down.

    It’s a very odd kind of racism here though. People will bend over backwards to help you, IF you ask. They are very nice and extremely polite, to your face. Otherwise they will go to lengths to avoid you, even crossing to the other side of the street.

  • http://www.tofugu.com Viet

    Approve


    Viet Hoang

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    lol, beat you to it, apparently.

  • http://www.tofugu.com Viet

    Yea.. but it isn’t showing up on the main website?

  • http://www.tofugu.com Viet

    Yeah… But I deleted your approval!

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    I see it, though disqus has been a bit weird today

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    oh schnap.
    apparently we didn’t do something right with the email reply
    thing…anyways, going to sleep, nightynight

  • http://google.com Allison

    Racism happens, whether there is a sign or not. A couple I know live in downtown Nagoya and tried to go to a restaurant within walking distance of their apartment. They were greeted with a Japanese woman crossing her arms, giving them the universal sign for no entry. And on the train, the seat beside you is the last seat to fill up, if they even choose to sit beside you. One time I entered onto a train, two high school girls looked at me, looked at each other then walked out of the train to enter another car down.

    It’s a very odd kind of racism here though. People will bend over backwards to help you, IF you ask. They are very nice and extremely polite, to your face. Otherwise they will go to lengths to avoid you, even crossing to the other side of the street.

  • Ryan

    I lived in Okinawa for 18 months. There was some existance of this anti-gaijin thing, but in all honesty it was deserved. I dont know how many times I saw drunk-ass airman or marines smashing a planter box in the road or punching off car sideview mirrors. Americans are genarally overbearing and rude and loud. And thats when were sober. If I were Japanese, I wouldnt give any gaijin the benifit of the doubt.

  • http://www.tofugu.com Viet

    Sadly… Okinawans get the short end of the stick. Why have full blooded Japanese deal with the US military when they can toss the problem to the minority group?

    Gaijin treatment may be bad, but the Japanese likes to treat their own subgroups a lot worse. Read up on the burakumin. They are sort of the Japanese version of the Indian untouchables.

  • Ryan

    I recently went on a trip to Japan for three weeks, and much of it was spent with university students (all around twenty years old). Our entire group received nothing but love and respect from the students we came across. We even had a couple weeboos in our group (it was a school-run trip), and even they were at least respected. We got so close to the students by the end of the trip (alcohol certainly helped admittedly) that almost everyone was crying on the day we left.

    During a conversation I had with one of the university students, and he told me flat out that racial intolerance is something that makes his blood boil, and that he never understood it. Keep in mind, that I’m a 6′ lanky white guy with big, curly brown hair and blue eyes.

    The group that we hung out with in Japan was almost entirely made up of people who had been to America the previous year on a reverse of the trip we were on (our schools are sister schools or something). They said that they received so much kindness from the American students, that they were paying it forward to us. Anyway, when people talk about all the Japanese being xenophobic, they obviously experienced Japan in a completely different way than I did (but of course, I got plenty of stares just walking down the street, but that is understandable). I made many very close friends during my time in Japan.

  • Menrui

    I got ricked rolled

  • Alexis

    I am a white american teenage girl who is really tall and has light-ish hair and really light eyes and i am going to Japan, I will be visiting a few big cities and a few small ones, including Tokyo. How will people treat me?

  • http://tofugu.com Tofugu_Erin

    To be honest, probably really well. Just be polite and don’t make a scene, and I’m sure you’ll be well-received. The fact that you’re a tall America/European-looking girl won’t hurt, either.

  • Eringu

    When my school visited Japan most people were very nice. We visited major cities so we saw a lot of gaijin. Every one was very nice though, only real issue was to try to get people to speak any Japanese to us.

    One kinda funny thing was that people didn’t like to be near us on trains. At one point we got on a packed train, yet still had room because they scrunched towards each other so they wouldn’t touch us. People were generally ok with me sitting near them, but my friend who is fourth Japanese had the issue that people would get up and find a new bench when he sat down.

  • Rohi

    You are right! My grandma was passing Japan on the way to America to visit me through Delta Airlines. She was openly discriminated against, and didn’t recieve any food during her flight. She is South Asian/Tamil. Sometimes I worry about going to Japan. I know everyone isn’t like that, but still. I hope I can have a good experience in Japan!

  • http://www.myspace.com/stuka82 Stuka

    Japanese men with thumb sized dicks must be threatened by the gaijins because gaijins can get more women than them, LOL

  • http://izeyhec.blogspot.com/ Izeyhec

    i wasnt aware that this problem was still around i mean i guess that is culture for you some times things just stay hard wired in to places

  • Daemon

    You know, most of the reports I’ve heard of “no gaijin” signs and the like were connected with mizu shoubai…

    I’ve also heard that it is at least technically illegal in Japan for a business to ban gaijin as a class.

  • http://www.myspace.com/heatlessangel heartlessangel

    ok so I know wat this article was about but I got so side tracked with Adam and Joe’s beautiful Tokyo song lol so funny わかりました

  • Harlekini

    In Sweden, we’re used to taking our shoes off, but perhaps not in a dressing room. Made a fool of myself…

  • bobi

    That's nothing. I ride on train carts…alone.

  • Vicky

    Everyone who I have spoken to who have been to Japan have been treated very well. My friend did have one experience though. She used a public bath and when she got in, the two Japanese women who were already in got out. I think that this was more a worried 'oh my god, I don't speak English, and they probably don't speak Japanese, how do we handle this awkward situation…I know! We will just leave!' I don't think it was meant as an act of racism, and probably many of these signs are misunderstood. I went to Germany a few years ago and on the whole, the German locals were very nice and accomodating, however once they learned that I spoke a little German and mainly English, they made their hasty excuses and left rather than face an awkward situation.

    Can't condone racism in any form, but I do think that alot is to do with a breakdown in communications and that scare monger rumours are frightening people into either not visiting other countries or clouding their judgement so that they go with an air of 'no one's gonna get away with being racist to me!' Which would instantly put anyone's back up!

    I'll get down off my soapbox now ;)

  • Ana_chan

    Heh, I really like the picture (has to be because I'm a baka gaijin who gets excited whenever she understands a few kana–sigh) and the videos are funny too. Thanks!

    I don't have any experience as far as the “no gaijin” signs are concerned, though I am as worried as everybody else since I'll soon go to Japan for the first time. “Gaijin” stand out no matter what. It doesn't mean we have to act like great brutes to live up to the image of the Ultimate Rude Foreigner. I mean, learning the language and having respect for the culture is the least one can do. Besides, isn't it the same in every country, Asian or not, when one is a foreigner? Of course, it's not as easy as it sounds, but still. It doesn't hurt to try, right?

  • Ana_chan

    To Fujiko,

    Um. Warning: I don't know how to express my thoughts without sounding like a fool so I apologize in advance.

    I really wanted to thank you for your comment about having some sort of nihonjin no tamashii inside. I'm not conceited enough to think that I was the only one feeling this sort of irrational connection to the Japanese culture, but heck if it's an easy thing to admit. I have to say, I don't really believe in reincarnation, it's more like, I *want* to believe in it (but I'm feeling too disillusioned about religious beliefs and human kind in general, sorry) but in any case, I wonder why I've always had these weird urges to bow and apologize all the time; I'm fascinated by the Japanese language, when learning it, I feel like I'm finally reuniting with something long lost, listening to a song I had somehow forgotten and always wished to remember. I really long to be part of this culture (again?) even though I will never really be, because I was born a “gaijin”. The only explanation I've come up with so far is, I must be a closet masochist. Mh, I think Freud would have a field day with this.

    Anyway, thank you for being nice to us people who usually won't dare speak up our mind because others laugh at us.

    And now I feel incredibly embarrassed.

    Don't hesitate to tell me if I completely misunderstood your feelings and thoughts. I'll just go and bury myself in shame somewhere.

  • http://www.myspace.com/kiyoshi Kiyoshi

    Having lived in Japan for both parts of high school and college, I can say that racism is getting worse, if anything.

    I speak Japanese and even have a Japanese name (adopted), and think it's more of the “closet” racism that's a problem than these outright racist practices of barring foreigners from some establishments.

    You can speak Japanese, have a work visa, a Japanese name, etc… but if you don't look Japanese, it seems Japan is only fun for a visit for some people.

    Unless you like being the monkey boy token friend, that is…

    Situations like these improve as the older, racist-ier generation dies out.

  • missy

    Never encountered the signs. I did have a bit of a problem with the whole “talk about them because we assume they don't speak Japanese” thing. Not the “oh it's a gaijin” thing (you kinda get used to that) but the “why the hell is /that/ here” thing. I think I just remember those the most clearly, though. They certainly weren't in the majority.

    The looks on their faces when you tell them you understood what they just said makes it a little better though. :3

  • Digger

    (I know this is an old post, but I can't help but respond.)

    You're writing a comment against discrimination, so hopefully you'll concede that some southerners (many of us, in fact) *do* have class. Many of us strongly reject racism and show an active interest in other cultures. Just so ya' know….

  • Natasha

    Do south asians really have it worse? I thought they'd be treated better than chinese or koreans!! 0__o

  • Stella

    I find it ironic that they're saying “good-bye” to Gaijin….. in english. I mean, really. “bai bai Gaijin”?? Wouldn't it be more appropriate to say “sayonara”?

    Either way, it's funny :D

  • http://femalenudity.blogspot.com female

    Thanks,very interesting and useful post

  • Ariel

    What do Japanese people think about Americans that are partly Japanese?
    I am 25% Japanese, and my sisters and my half Japanese mother and uncle are thinking about going to Japan. If there is any racism towards Americans, do you think we would be as shunned if we are part Japanese?

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    Half/Part Japanese is the new sexy. You’ll be fine :)

  • Sullz

    Well that was awkward.

    A few months back I was reading this blog while my Japanese exchange student was watching TV in my room. I played the first video, and after it was done she got up and forced me to play it again… D: After watching it she was a bit of a jerk to me the whole time she was here. I'm guessing this is an unspoken issue in Japan, or maybe her family is stricter than others. Shrug.

  • http://tofugu.com Tofugu_Erin

    Ah, that's no fun.

    Sorry about that!