Should Men, Or Women, Be Paying For A Date?

I recently wrote “Dating A Foreigner (From A Japanese Perspective)” and I received a lot of interesting feedback and I thank you all. One particularly resounding message from you all was that many people wanted to hear perspectives other than my own and of course I agreed with you. On the other hand, it’s difficult to cover many topics with a lot of perspectives all at one time, so I’ve decided to go at this topic by topic.

Before getting started, I’d like to point out again that all these examples could just be personal character traits, flaws, habits, beliefs, or senses of humor and that not all Japanese people act the same way. In fact, I found one to be quite rude and atypical. There are no generalizations because the people quoted in this article dated different people from different countries and they all have their own personalities. So, keep that in mind!

So, don’t be upset if an example related to your nationality and it doesn’t match with the way you think or feel! I’m not taking a jab at your country, and everyone knows that every person in the world has different experiences. Let’s just have some fun with this and maybe learn something along the way.

Is It True That Japanese Men Pay For Women?

unsure-01

In Japan, many people still believe that men paying for women is point of good manners and Koichi talked about this in What It’s Like A Dating a Japanese Guy as well. In fact, some guys even feel insulted, or that their pride was just given a ‘low-blow’, if a woman insists that she should pay for herself. This is standard dating-conduct for men in Japan. So, if you are a non-Japanese girl out on your first date with a Japanese guy, insisting to pay your half may be more hurtful than helpful to his pride.

But wait a minute! This has been changing quite a lot actually, especially amongst the newer generation of couples. Nowadays, many men wish more women would help pay for the date tab. It’s also more common for men to ask women to contribute somewhere between 20-30%. If at no point does the woman offer to pay for something, then the man may actually be lead to believe that she is not a generous or thoughtful person!

According to a research study conducted by Sankei Digital and Sankei Living from December 19, 2012 to January 15, 2013, about 70% of 169 Japanese women still prefer to be paid for while on the date. Actually, this research made many Japanese men upset to the point where they cried out “Where the heck is man-woman equality!?” I guess to be safe you should at least offer to pay, and hopefully they will reject your offer (if you didn’t want to pay)? With these ideas changing so rapidly, be careful not to step on any hurt-feelings landmines.

Men Of The Younger Generation (Kids These Days!)

fiftyfifty-01

Japanese men who have been educated throughout school and from societal constructs about ‘the equality of men and women’ often question the male’s responsibilities. In this article, of course that means paying for things like restaurant bills and such. I came across an interview from a man who was dating his coworker. The interview was conducted by Fukuishinbun.

In the interview, he complained that he pays a little more than his girlfriend when they go out on a date, even though the receive the same payment from their company. He believes that they should pay the same amount if their payment is exactly the same.

This change in Japanese men’s thinking was also brough up last year by a Chinese woman who was dating a Japanese guy. On their first date, they split the bill and this made her so upset that she wrote down her complaints on her blog. What she wrote took the online news sources by storm.

I had no idea why I had to pay because it was a date with my boyfriend. In China, or at least in Zhejiang where I am from, the man pays for practically everything while on dates. I’d say that the restaurant bill should be almost 100%. In fact, if a woman pays, she risks being hated by her boyfriend.

It’s not only this Chinese girl, though. Another Chinese girl (劉), a Korean girl (ハン) and an anonymous Laotian girl were also all surprised that their Japanese boyfriends didn’t pay for them. As for ハン, she was so upset when her boyfriend tried to split the bill for a ラブホテル (Love hotel) that she left him in anger.

I’m not sure about how old the Japanese guys were, but all three of these women are in their late teens and early twenties, so I assume they were dating guys who would be considered to be part of the “younger” generation. The older generation of men still expect that men should pay for women… however, younger generations are changing, so it may be best to be flexible on that stereotype.

Furthermore, one anonymous Japanese guy dating a British woman was often told by her: “I can’t believe Japanese women. They allow men to split bills because they don’t have confidence in themselves!” He used to split the bill when he was dating Japanese women, but he had to change his mind after hearing that line, at least for her. Over time, be began to get annoyed with what she said because she repeatedly complained about Japanese women who allow men to split the bill. It’s possible that the myth that all Japanese men prefer paying for everything may not have a long life if he felt this way.

Women That Prefer To Be Paid For

nope-01

Like the above research suggested, many Japanese women still believe that their portion of the cost of a date should still be paid for. I also know of many Japanese girls who believe that men should always pay for women and that women should only date men who pay for them. @ya is maybe one of them and was surprised at how differently things are done in the UK.

In England, there is the concept that ‘give and take’ between a man and a woman should be equal. Regardless of whether or not it is a first date or a date between a couple with a long lasting relationship, it is pretty common to split the bill. Actually, just as a side point, you may want to be weary of a guy who insists on paying for you on the first date as it might be a sign that he is looking for a chance to sleep with you. Anyhow, I personally get annoyed by the person who puts forth so much effort to split the bill perfectly down the middle. (Hold on a second, let me root around the bottom of my purse for the 4 pennies I owe you.)

Yamaihimiko dated an American guy and she mentioned that he fronted the bill for everything, whereas inokay1123, who dated a few American men in the past, said that they all wished to split the bill and she stopped seeing them because of that. Actually, she brought up an interesting thing.

Just like many Japanese people do, I offered to pay my own bill to show my appreciation and gestured that I would hand over my money. Then, they just simply accepted it.

So, if you’re a guy who is seeking the chance to date a Japanese woman, you may want to question yourself when she poses this option. If she does offer to pay, maybe you should just say, “Don’t worry. It’s on me.” There’s a chance she’s not actually wanting to pay for half of the bill, but she’s just doing so to be polite.

Although some Japanese women complain that their international boyfriend doesn’t pay their bill, one anonymous woman who was dating a man from Thailand was very impressed. The whole bill was on him, even when she took her sister or friends. Apparently, it’s even pretty common for Thai men to borrow money from their friends before going on a date to help pay for it. It’s also normal for men to either provide their girlfriends with a ride to work, school, or accompany them to their destination, but it depends on his income as the transportation can change from bus to motorcycle to taxi to car to hovercraft.

It Doesn’t Bother Me!

yep-01

As for me, personally, sure I like free food, but I didn’t care whether my boyfriend paid for me or not every time. Even now that I’m married it doesn’t matter… though that might be because there is only one wallet (our wallet). I had an ex-boyfriend who suggested that we decide who pays the bill by playing rock-paper-scissors. I accepted and from there on out we always decided that way. I found it pretty fair and kind of fun, too. While dating my Canadian husband, sometimes he would pay for me and other times I would pay for myself. It didn’t bother me, especially because I knew that I was making more money than him at the time, haha!

So, now you see that it’s not so black and white. While it’s still very much standard for the older generations to pay for a woman’s meals and date, the younger generation is changing. Some girls still expect it, other girls do not. Same with guys too. Best thing you can do if you’re a non-Japanese person dating a Japanese person is to be sure and offer if you’re a girl and attempt to reject payment offers if you’re a guy. It’s basic manners, anyways.

How does your country work in regards to this topic? Or, have you had experiences with Japanese women / men when it comes to paying for the date?

  • Musouka

    Ah, the mighty 割り勘

    It makes more sense in groups since my Japanese friends tend to share the food. For couples, I’d say it’s either one pays or each pay their own bill. I like how in the US, the shops can give individuals separate bills and process several cards.

  • nuray

    hmm

  • lychalis

    When I first went out with my now boyfriend, he fronted the bill at the restaurant we were at. After that, if we went to a restaurant we would each pay our halves, same with at the cinema – sometimes he would pay my half, but I’d always find a way to pay him back and vice-versa. This has continued for the three years we’ve been together, unless one of us is treating the other (During the summer just past, I bought him a meal at wagamama and took him to see Rise of the Guardians for a treat :D)

  • Mami

    You two are very faithful to the equality(>v<) I think that it's a good idea, too. Do you sometimes have a trouble deciding if the purchase belongs to shared expenses or your individual expenses? Or, was it pretty easy to decide the border, too?

  • Mami

    constipated??

  • Mami

    Yeah, I like the US and Canada way, too. In Japan, if you tried to pay individuals, some restaurant give you a bad face or even say ‘sorry, we don’t accept individual payment’. I don’t like it:(

  • Mami

    That’s very true! :D

  • Mami

    Wow, I’ve never heard of the ‘date wallet’. Maybe it’s new thing for young people, too? I don’t know, but it sounds very practical!!!

  • Maria Liss

    It was not so big party but our bill was for almost 500$ and he wanted to pay for everything and for all my friends! Unexpectedly! ^o^

  • Jonathan Harston

    A shimi sobakasu is patches of melanomin (the skin pigment that causes freckles) that appear due to sunlight and remain as the skin gradually loses its ability to return to an untanned colouring.

    Acne is skin secretions blocking sweat pores or hair follicle pores.

    Blemish is any kind of long-lasting natural skin change. Acne can leave the skin blemished with bumps. Sunburn can leave the skin blemished with increased “liver spots”. Injury or surgery can leave the skin blemished with tight or smooth patches.

    Shimi sobakasu: http://www.akaikeskincare.com/syourei/shimi0114.jpg

    Liver spots: http://www.defoodgrade.com/images/age_spots-2.jpg

  • Jonathan Harston

    The first time I took my girlfriend out for a meal I assumed she’d want something non-Japanese, but she spotted Wagamama and said: oo, Japanese food, let’s go there. The really weird part was eating in a restaurant called “Egotistical”. ;)

  • Jonathan Harston

    When I was married 15 years ago we had a shared account, but put the same amount in to cover shared expenses regardless of our individual incomes. If one of us wanted to spend their personal money on the other they could do that as a gift/treat.
    Deciding what was shared expenses was fairly simple: keeping a roof over our head, shared food. Everything else was personal expenses.

  • Mescale

    Dakimakura-tan looks after all my money anyway so she always pays when we go out to restaurants.

  • lychalis

    hahaha I’d always thought it’d meant ‘selfish’ x3

    we actually went to nando’s first time we went out. Should mention, both of us are western so I suppose paying our halves would come more naturally. Free food is great, but I get uncomfortable with the idea of the other constanly paying for me >.<

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/YAMAstudios Jon Walmsley

    For first date situations it depends on what you’re paying for. If its just coffee, I think the man showing his willingness to pay the
    full bill is important in showing the woman that he’s neither a cheapskate nor ungenerous, so long as you say something fun like “next time though, for the sake of gender equality, I must insist that the bill is on you, promise?”. This is to make it clear you aren’t an ass-kissing pushover by paying the bill but are rather doing her a gentlemanly favour. However, if it’s a more expensive bill I’d probably suggest a rough split as you shouldn’t be paying loads of money on someone you don’t even know that you’re going to see again. Though I wouldn’t go anywhere expensive for first dates anyway (restaurant, cinema etc) as its boring and predictable and first dates are best as shorter affairs in my experience. That’s my two cents anyway.

  • http://kaska.jp/ Jonas

    I guess so, yeah. It’s an interesting solution!

  • Niklas Barsk

    That’s not nice. I haven’t been to that many restaurants in Japan but I got the impression that you pretty much always pay at the cashier and saying that you want to pay べつべつ is just fine and on top of that you never give any tip.

    I really like that and it feels so much more convenient than how things work when I’ve been out with colleagues for dinner after work sometime here in Sweden. Here you have to try to get hold of a waiter to get the bill to the table and that’s a bill for everyone. Then everyone tries to calculate how much they should pay and those who pay with cash starts pooling up the correct sum and changing bigger bills for smaller between each other or the money that’s been pooled up for the bill. Then of course there are always some that want to pay with card so part of the bill is payed with one or several cards.

    And finally you have to decide if you should tip anything or not. It’s not really custom to tip here, but on the other hand some people thing that you should be tipping when you’re out for dinner on a restaurant. So usually people just round up the bill, or their part or the bill to the nearest convenient amount (maybe around 0-5% tip) and feel bad for giving a too small or too big tip.

    So it’s always a hassle to pay the bill when eating out with friends.

  • Niklas Barsk

    No we haven’t had any problems or discussion on where to draw the line. I don’t think we’ve even discussed it, it just comes naturally. Expenses related to the house, car, food, our kid, travels we do together are shared while other things are personal.

    We don’t have to struggle to make the money last every month and none of us are big at spending money or thinks that having lots of money is important so I guess this makes it easier for us. So if my wife would buy something once with our shared money that I think is something personal for her I wouldn’t really mind or mention it unless it’s something really expensive.

  • Little Wonder

    It’s called a liver spot because the spots sometimes appear to be shaped like the liver.

  • Lucie

    When I used to date guys (before settling into a long term relationship) I always used to feel really awkward if a guy tried to pay for everything, if I have my own money why shouldn’t I pay for what I’ve eaten?

  • Mami

    I see:D Thank you for explaining! I like your system:)

  • Mami

    That sounds very fair:D

  • Mami

    yeah(*´∀`*)

  • Mami

    Awww…Thank you…(TT) I’m scared…

  • Mami

    Oh, I see! Thank you:D

  • Mami

    arigatou(*´∀`*)

  • Mami

    Do you feel only guys? In Japan, it’s also common that older people pay everything or a little more than you:) Would you feel awkward that way, too?

  • Mami

    (*´∀`*) Is she pretty?❤

  • Mami

    Wow, he is a very nice guy❤:D I like your profile picture btw.

  • Mami

    Thank you for sharing your experience:D What kind of movie would you choose for the first date? Is Love story common? Just my curiosity…

  • Mami

    Ah, nice❤ Is your boyfriend Japanese, if I may ask?

  • Mami

    Wow! :P Did the restaurant name make you guys laugh?? :D

  • Mami

    wagagamama means selfish or egotistical or drum your own march or etc :D
    Where is nando’s??? Sorry, I asked if your boyfriend is Japanese because I hadn’t read this post! Now I know both of you are western.

  • Jonathan Harston

    They’re completely benign (non-dangerous). Any skin blemishes that are the start of something malign are generally sore, mis-shapen, unevenly coloured, “lumpy”, etc.

  • Mami

    Yeah, it’s a little hustle, isn’t it? Someone paying everything and splitting by ourselves is pretty common Japan, too. We usually divide by the number of people to avoid such caluculating-chaos. Although some restaurants (especially big one) allow you to pay betsubetsu like you said, it’s also considered to be a little impolite to the restaurant when people are so many. It’s often considered to be a part of manner especially if you are adults, so we often calculate later. If it’s a company drinking party, your distribution could change depends on your status in the company as well. You pay on the day or the next day at your office. It definitely makes things easier that we don’t have tip culture though.

  • martinu

    I don’t understand how is it polite to offer to split the bill without actually wanting to pay. If you don’t want to split it, simply don’t offer to do so.

  • Mami

    Maybe orangedude ‘s comment explains….

  • Mescale

    She is, I just can’t wait until the day she lets me turn her over…

  • Nick Hattan

    Your progression of topics along with Aya’s art is hilarious xDD Did you guys talk about it?
    Also, I always prefer to pay the tab (I’m a guy). Sometimes I try to, but the girl insists. America’s weird, Mami. Don’t travel too much further south than you are :V

  • Mami

    No, I didn’t talk about it. I think it’s all Aya’s idea:D and I love it too! lol
    aha, maybe I skip America and fly further south to South America. How’s that?

  • Mami

    She hasn’t yet? Does she have a boy dakimakura friend?

  • Vicky

    It makes me sad how some women find more joy in being “treated” to things rather than the pride of doing it for themselves.

  • Mescale

    We’re waiting until after marriage.

    Sorry Mami but we don’t double-dakimakura-date. But I’m sure there’s a dakimakura out there for you, maybe, in the shape of a Shinkansen.

  • Maria Liss

    Yes! He loves me!
    Ahah thank you, fear Mami:)

  • 肉人

    “It’s basic manners, anyways.” This quote pretty much sums it up for me, both sides should offer to pay and it’s all about reading your partner after that.

    But still, I think it’s all good as long as the whole thing is resolved smoothly and preferably with no casualties :D

  • Aker

    Before I had a girlfriend, I dated with
    couple of Japanese girls and always we shared the bill when I started dating
    with my girlfriend too, and was OK. However, may be, my case is a little bit
    different, because at that time I was a student and the girls that I dated knew
    it.

  • Endar

    When it comes down to it, more splitting = more dates. I haven’t dated a Japanese girl, but I would be annoyed if she expected me to pay for her. It just doesn’t make sense to me. This is one of few situations that women seem to have to advantage in an unequal situation.

    That being said, what about Japanese women paying for the whole ticket? Does that happen? Sometimes with my American girlfriend we just trade off who pays, depending on the circumstances. Like you said, you played RPS to see who pays with one person, but how common is that?

  • pantinaprovina

    I think that the man paying for everything comes from a time when women didn’t actually have any of their own money. Now that women are prominent in the workforce it makes sense that people would move away from the ‘man pays for everything’ mindset.

    I now have the same method with dates that I do with close friends. When they grab the bill I’ll ask, “Do you know how much mine is?” And if they say, “Oh don’t worry about it, I’ve got this.” I’ll offer to pay for both of ours the next time and we’ll probably end up ‘taking turns’. If they tell me my portion or hand back the bill to me, I’ll pay for my half and do that from then on.

    I’ve never met anyone that insisted on paying all the time that was my own age. People from at least a generation ahead of me have always insisted on paying every time, but I’ve always felt it came from an attitude of like parents taking care of their kids.

  • Time

    I have been living in America for over 17 years now. It has always been taught to me however that the guy pays unless the girl asks. It seems to work for most people.

  • lychalis

    nah, we’re both British