Should Men, Or Women, Be Paying For A Date?

I recently wrote “Dating A Foreigner (From A Japanese Perspective)” and I received a lot of interesting feedback and I thank you all. One particularly resounding message from you all was that many people wanted to hear perspectives other than my own and of course I agreed with you. On the other hand, it’s difficult to cover many topics with a lot of perspectives all at one time, so I’ve decided to go at this topic by topic.

Before getting started, I’d like to point out again that all these examples could just be personal character traits, flaws, habits, beliefs, or senses of humor and that not all Japanese people act the same way. In fact, I found one to be quite rude and atypical. There are no generalizations because the people quoted in this article dated different people from different countries and they all have their own personalities. So, keep that in mind!

So, don’t be upset if an example related to your nationality and it doesn’t match with the way you think or feel! I’m not taking a jab at your country, and everyone knows that every person in the world has different experiences. Let’s just have some fun with this and maybe learn something along the way.

Is It True That Japanese Men Pay For Women?

unsure-01

In Japan, many people still believe that men paying for women is point of good manners and Koichi talked about this in What It’s Like A Dating a Japanese Guy as well. In fact, some guys even feel insulted, or that their pride was just given a ‘low-blow’, if a woman insists that she should pay for herself. This is standard dating-conduct for men in Japan. So, if you are a non-Japanese girl out on your first date with a Japanese guy, insisting to pay your half may be more hurtful than helpful to his pride.

But wait a minute! This has been changing quite a lot actually, especially amongst the newer generation of couples. Nowadays, many men wish more women would help pay for the date tab. It’s also more common for men to ask women to contribute somewhere between 20-30%. If at no point does the woman offer to pay for something, then the man may actually be lead to believe that she is not a generous or thoughtful person!

According to a research study conducted by Sankei Digital and Sankei Living from December 19, 2012 to January 15, 2013, about 70% of 169 Japanese women still prefer to be paid for while on the date. Actually, this research made many Japanese men upset to the point where they cried out “Where the heck is man-woman equality!?” I guess to be safe you should at least offer to pay, and hopefully they will reject your offer (if you didn’t want to pay)? With these ideas changing so rapidly, be careful not to step on any hurt-feelings landmines.

Men Of The Younger Generation (Kids These Days!)

fiftyfifty-01

Japanese men who have been educated throughout school and from societal constructs about ‘the equality of men and women’ often question the male’s responsibilities. In this article, of course that means paying for things like restaurant bills and such. I came across an interview from a man who was dating his coworker. The interview was conducted by Fukuishinbun.

In the interview, he complained that he pays a little more than his girlfriend when they go out on a date, even though the receive the same payment from their company. He believes that they should pay the same amount if their payment is exactly the same.

This change in Japanese men’s thinking was also brough up last year by a Chinese woman who was dating a Japanese guy. On their first date, they split the bill and this made her so upset that she wrote down her complaints on her blog. What she wrote took the online news sources by storm.

I had no idea why I had to pay because it was a date with my boyfriend. In China, or at least in Zhejiang where I am from, the man pays for practically everything while on dates. I’d say that the restaurant bill should be almost 100%. In fact, if a woman pays, she risks being hated by her boyfriend.

It’s not only this Chinese girl, though. Another Chinese girl (劉), a Korean girl (ハン) and an anonymous Laotian girl were also all surprised that their Japanese boyfriends didn’t pay for them. As for ハン, she was so upset when her boyfriend tried to split the bill for a ラブホテル (Love hotel) that she left him in anger.

I’m not sure about how old the Japanese guys were, but all three of these women are in their late teens and early twenties, so I assume they were dating guys who would be considered to be part of the “younger” generation. The older generation of men still expect that men should pay for women… however, younger generations are changing, so it may be best to be flexible on that stereotype.

Furthermore, one anonymous Japanese guy dating a British woman was often told by her: “I can’t believe Japanese women. They allow men to split bills because they don’t have confidence in themselves!” He used to split the bill when he was dating Japanese women, but he had to change his mind after hearing that line, at least for her. Over time, be began to get annoyed with what she said because she repeatedly complained about Japanese women who allow men to split the bill. It’s possible that the myth that all Japanese men prefer paying for everything may not have a long life if he felt this way.

Women That Prefer To Be Paid For

nope-01

Like the above research suggested, many Japanese women still believe that their portion of the cost of a date should still be paid for. I also know of many Japanese girls who believe that men should always pay for women and that women should only date men who pay for them. @ya is maybe one of them and was surprised at how differently things are done in the UK.

In England, there is the concept that ‘give and take’ between a man and a woman should be equal. Regardless of whether or not it is a first date or a date between a couple with a long lasting relationship, it is pretty common to split the bill. Actually, just as a side point, you may want to be weary of a guy who insists on paying for you on the first date as it might be a sign that he is looking for a chance to sleep with you. Anyhow, I personally get annoyed by the person who puts forth so much effort to split the bill perfectly down the middle. (Hold on a second, let me root around the bottom of my purse for the 4 pennies I owe you.)

Yamaihimiko dated an American guy and she mentioned that he fronted the bill for everything, whereas inokay1123, who dated a few American men in the past, said that they all wished to split the bill and she stopped seeing them because of that. Actually, she brought up an interesting thing.

Just like many Japanese people do, I offered to pay my own bill to show my appreciation and gestured that I would hand over my money. Then, they just simply accepted it.

So, if you’re a guy who is seeking the chance to date a Japanese woman, you may want to question yourself when she poses this option. If she does offer to pay, maybe you should just say, “Don’t worry. It’s on me.” There’s a chance she’s not actually wanting to pay for half of the bill, but she’s just doing so to be polite.

Although some Japanese women complain that their international boyfriend doesn’t pay their bill, one anonymous woman who was dating a man from Thailand was very impressed. The whole bill was on him, even when she took her sister or friends. Apparently, it’s even pretty common for Thai men to borrow money from their friends before going on a date to help pay for it. It’s also normal for men to either provide their girlfriends with a ride to work, school, or accompany them to their destination, but it depends on his income as the transportation can change from bus to motorcycle to taxi to car to hovercraft.

It Doesn’t Bother Me!

yep-01

As for me, personally, sure I like free food, but I didn’t care whether my boyfriend paid for me or not every time. Even now that I’m married it doesn’t matter… though that might be because there is only one wallet (our wallet). I had an ex-boyfriend who suggested that we decide who pays the bill by playing rock-paper-scissors. I accepted and from there on out we always decided that way. I found it pretty fair and kind of fun, too. While dating my Canadian husband, sometimes he would pay for me and other times I would pay for myself. It didn’t bother me, especially because I knew that I was making more money than him at the time, haha!

So, now you see that it’s not so black and white. While it’s still very much standard for the older generations to pay for a woman’s meals and date, the younger generation is changing. Some girls still expect it, other girls do not. Same with guys too. Best thing you can do if you’re a non-Japanese person dating a Japanese person is to be sure and offer if you’re a girl and attempt to reject payment offers if you’re a guy. It’s basic manners, anyways.

How does your country work in regards to this topic? Or, have you had experiences with Japanese women / men when it comes to paying for the date?

  • orangedude

    Personally I’m happy to pay for my date, until it’s expected that I pay. It may seem stupid, but I’ll give you the shirt off of my back unless you expect me to do so.

  • Hanna

    I am fine with any of those. I can pay, we can split, or he can pay. I have been married too long to know what kids these days are doing in the US.

  • Maria

    I have a Japanese boyfriend and I am Russian. Actually, my boyfriend pays 100% of a bill but I guess he prefers sometimes I help him.
    But, when I had a birthday party he wanted to pay for all!! I was shocked

  • missingno15
  • dennmart

    I don’t mind paying for everything when going out on a date. But it’s nearly impossible (in my experience) to lump men and women into these groups of who wants / should be paying when out on a date. While studies (like the one mentioned here) can be an indicator, I truly believe that it’s all up to each individual person. Everyone is very different in these cases.

    The majority of American women I have dated in the past seem to expect me to pay for everything, especially early on in the relationship. Sure, they do the whole “Oh, let me pay for my part” check dance that happens awkwardly sometimes, but in the end they happily accepted me footing the bill. However, my current girlfriend, who’s Japanese, has always somewhat forcefully made me accept her paying for half of what we do, to the point that she would get a little angry if I went behind her back and paid for everything on a given day. I quickly learned from that – you don’t want to see a Japanese woman angry at you :)

  • Tora.Silver

    I don’t blame Han for leaving that love hotel. After all, Han…
    ( •_•)>⌐■-■
    prefers to be solo.
    (⌐■_■)

  • Saimu-san

    I don’t have so much experience with dating considering I’d only went out with friends in Glasgow but even if we went out as a group of about five or six there was a tradition of everybody paying for their own meals rather than paying an equal amount for everyone. I think that’s the system I like adopting with everyone I eat a meal with. I hate owing people money and if I feel like I’ve paid too much or too little for my share of something it could ruin a good night… Mostly because I pester the person I owe to take my money when I try to pay them back! Lol.

  • Jonathan Harston

    When I was dating a Japanese girl 25 years ago we tended to swap rather than split individual bills – it’s ok, I’ll pay, you paid last time. The week we stayed at my family’s seaside cottage she paid for most things as I’d sorted out the accommodation. (Cottage sounds so swanky, my great-grandmother’s house that the family had inherited and we shared between the 15 of us.)
    I back to dating a Japanese woman again, and again we tend to swap, or cases of I’ve done all the driving, she insists on paying for the food.
    I’ve always felt uncomfortable with the concept of men paying for everything for a women, it feels too much like purchasing the woman and the implicit (explicit in some men’s minds) purchasing her body as well.

  • Jonathan Harston

    “my great-grandmother’s house that the family had inherited and we shared between the 15 of us”
    God, that sounds even worse. My great-grandmother’s small house that her 15 descendants inherited, that we arranged between us to use from time to time as a sort-of timeshare holiday cottage. The one with a separate bathroom and toilet – see last week’s discussion. :)

  • Mami

    Thank you for sharing your experience. I’ve experienced the swap system, too. It’s a good idea, too. As for guys paying everything, one of my friends, who believe that guys should pay everything, was told by her boyfriend that she should help him pay sometimes, too. She said, ‘Ok. On the next date, then.’ On the day, she showed up at the meeting place without any make-up and told him, ‘You said you don’t pay and that means I don’t put my make-up on because cosmetics are very expensive.’ Well, it worked for them and he started paying for her again. This wouldn’t work for me though. I don’t usually put make-up on my face:P

  • Mami

    Ah, you are very 謙虚(けんきょ/kenkyo/modest/humble).

  • Mami

    ▄█▀█●ガーン

  • Mami

    Hmmm…how do you judge that it was expected?

  • Mami

    OMG! LOL.

  • Jonathan Harston

    Well, that’s because all Japanese women are beautiful whether they wear makeup or not. (^v^)

  • Mami

    I see:) Thank you for sharing your opinion♪

  • Mami

    Was it a big birthday party? Did he pay not only yours but all of your friends??

  • Mami

    That’s true. It’s not majority yet, but some of them prefer to pay on my own:) Do you comfortable to split, too?

  • Mami

    I see:P lol Thank you for sharing your experience and idea♪ I don’t like feeling me owing someone money either.

  • Jonathan Harston

    I’ve seen similar situations in Japan. Hibaba and Hijiji were farmers, their children moved to the city, and the grandchildren and great-grandchildren would go to visit in the holidays, when Hibaba and Hijjij dies nobody wants to be a farmer, so the rest of the family keep the house for visits instead of letting it fall down.

  • Mami

    The guy was Japanese and wanted her to put make-up on, so he started paying again, though! :P
    I’m just lazy…I feel I should because I’m getting a lot of シミ・そばかす(TT)←I don’t know how to write them in English…I think そばかす is freckles…but I’m not sure about shimi…

  • Mami

    I see. Yeah, that’s true! :D I said you are very humble because you changed your expression into ‘small house’ :P

  • Jonathan Harston

    I’m afraid all the english translations sound horrible: liver spot, old-age spot, senile freckle :(
    Medically known as hyperpigmentation. It’s one of those things that there doesn’t seem to be a neutral name for, probably to the benefit of the anti-age cosmetics industry.

  • orangedude

    If a girl at least offers to split the bill, then I know that she’s not immediately expecting me to pay, which is nice! :D

  • sexypizza

    This whole problem wouldn’t exist if we lived in a socialist world.

  • dennmart

    I don’t mind splitting the bill at all! Sometimes I just enjoy treating her to a day / night out occasionally without her spending any money :)

  • Sara.S

    I live in America in the south where the term “southern gentleman” is common. It is expected by many people for the man to pay for dates. I remember coming home from first dates with my parents asking, “did he pay?”. At least for the first date, I thought it was better for the man to pay. I have also offered to pay for my part of the meal while slightly hoping they wouldn’t accept just to be polite.
    Now though, I am in a long term relationship with someone and the issue of who pays doesn’t come up as much. We tend to take turns paying for meals and other outing expenses. If he seems to be paying for a lot of things, I will buy dinner next or tickets to the next movie, and he does the same for me.
    This system seems to work well for us as we don’t focus on the money as much but on the experience. Generally everything seems to even out pretty well.

  • Mami

    Right!

  • DAVIDPD

    In the beginning, always man, when “going steady”, switch off every other date.

  • niko

    My boyfriend always pays and never expects me to help. He once got a little snappy with me when I asked if I should pay my share and say, “I’m a man, I can pay for it.” He’ll pay for our whole day out sometimes. Once he forgot to withdraw money before we went on a day trip and I got to pay for everything, but he looked a bit dejected and told me he would pay me back as soon as he found an ATM. I appreciate he’s willingness to take care of things, but it isn’t necessary.

    I always ask a few times to help pay, because I genuinely don’t mind. Dating someone should never be about money (that’s immature and petty). It should be about spending time with someone you like/love. If it makes him happy to pay, let him. But if it makes you happy to pay, always offer.

  • Ely lioney

    This isn’t a date situation but one time when my family and family friends ate out (we were all Filipino) there was sort of a fight to who pays the bill. Every family would say that they’ll pay for it in full.
    In Australia, its a general consensus that when going out as a date or with friends, for everyone to pay for their part of the bill (but that can change if someone says they are treating).

  • mish

    person who does the asking pays.

    By the second date you can split.

  • mish

    Oh wait, split bill means in half? I thought it meant you pay for what you ordered…

  • Abu Abujafar

    Nice post! Very informative like the others you wrote before! =)
    I`m glad that things are changing with the new generation. I think when couples split the bill, it adds a sense of intimacy between then. Like they share an equal level of sympathy and love for each other.

  • Mami

    Sounds sweet:D

  • Mami

    Liver spot!? liver!?!?!? Why, liver!? Thank you very much anyway though. I’m just wondering…

  • Mami

    Is that true…?

  • Mami

    (*´艸`*)❤

  • Mami

    Wow, the first thing your parents asked was if he paid for you, eh? It’s pretty surprising(><)
    I think that it's a good system, too:D Thank you for sharing your experience!

  • Mami

    Thank you for sharing your experience! It’s cool that your boyfriend takes care of everything:) ❤❤And the best part is that you haven’t forgotten thankful mind for him and always ask to help him pay❤❤(๑❛ᴗ❛๑)♡ How nice!

  • Mami

    It’s interesting!!! Is the paying fight only common among Filipino??

  • Ely lioney

    I suppose it happens with other nationalities but I know for sure that this friendly fight happens with Filipinos.
    In a date situation my mum told me that usually it is the males that pays for the date in the Philippines.

  • Mami

    Oh, I meant both…in Japan, it’s possible to order for what you ordered, but it’s more common for someone to pay everything and divide the amount by the number of people later.

  • Mami

    (๑❛ᴗ❛๑)♡

  • Mami

    Thank you and I like your idea: they share an equal level of sympathy and love for each other.(๑❛ᴗ❛๑)♡

  • Mami

    Oh, I see. I guess in many countries that it’s standard for men to pay on dates (*´∀`*)

  • Ely lioney

    I’m thinking that because before its males that have the jobs and women if they did work, they would earn less is why they paid for everything. But now that their is more equality in the work force and women are earning more, it seems that the equality is being transferred to payments and other areas of life.

  • http://kaska.jp/ Jonas

    I think it makes sense to pay for the first few dates. I look at it as being an invitation, and most of the time it’s the man asking a woman out on a date. So my logic for paying is the same as any other invitation. The person who invites someone to do something is usually the one who pays (for smaller things, not like trips around the globe). Just like I wouldn’t ask my friends to pay for beer/snacks on a game night at my place for example.

    However, when you become a couple I expect not having to pay for everything. In my case we either split or take care of every other bill, but it’s sort of automatic, it’s not something we have to discuss after every meal. I probably end up paying a little more, which is fine.

    A few other friends of mine, who are dating a Japanese man or woman, have something like a “date wallet”. Basically they have an extra wallet that they both add money to every week or month, so they never have to think about money on those important dates. Seems like a smart solution^^

  • Niklas Barsk

    My Japanese wife and I have a shared bank account where we pay in money every month based on our income. My income is slightly higher than hers so I pay slightly more every month for that account. Then we have a shared credit card that we use for all our shared expenses such as grocery shopping and eating out. So it doesn’t matter who pays, it all goes on the same credit card bill which we pay of using money from our shared bank account.

    Having a setup like this was really important for me from the beginning so we can both feel like we are paying for a fair share of our shared expenses and are both equally responsible for our life together. My wife also thinks this is a good and fair setup.

  • Musouka

    I guess シミ could be Acne/Blemish or other types of discoloration?