Scoop Me Up, Buttercup: Goldfish in Paradoxical Japan

Modern day goldfish are believed to have descended from several red mutants of the Chinese funa carp. These mutants, or hibuna (ヒブナ), in turn mutated into the wakin (和金), the first goldfish that were brought into Japan in 1502. Since then, the humble wakin has given rise to dozens of varieties. However, only wakin has been given the honor of having wa or “of Japan” in its name, as befitting its status as the founding father of Japanese goldfish.

A living work of art…

Of course, the numerous goldfish varieties available nowadays didn’t just arise spontaneously. At the end of the Edo period, goldfish gradually went from just being exotic pets for the privileged, to being a living art form, and many new varieties were developed as breeders strove for perfection. (Fortuitous mutations played a part as well, but even then many years of careful breeding is needed to “fix” the characteristics of each variety.)

panda choubi, ranchuu, and bubble eye goldfish

Image sources: 1, 2, 3

The quest for the perfect goldfish continues to this day, as evidenced by the hobbyist clubs that specialise in the breeding and development of specific varieties. Takao Narisawa, a goldfish farmer, estimated that it will take him 20 years to breed the Shonai Sakura, a pearly-skinned, scaleless variety — goldfish breeding in Japan is certainly not just a simple pastime. There’s also the annual All Japan Ranchu Show, where ranchuu (らんちゅう) are judged on conformation and coloring, and the one deemed most splendid is bestowed a certificate signed by the Prime Minister.

… or a mere toy?

Despite how celebrated goldfish are in Japan, the plainer varieties can be deemed no more than a plaything. Goldfish scooping, or kingyo-sukui (金魚すくい), has been around since the Edo period, and is a common sight at many summer festivals. Usually, participants use a paper net, or poi (ポイ), to scoop goldfish from a shallow pool into a bowl. The game ends when the poi tears beyond use, at which point the fish they caught, if any, are bagged for them to take home.

goldfish scooping

Kingyo-sukui is more than just a festival attraction, however. In fact, it is so popular that a national championship is jointly held every year by the National Goldfish Scooping Organisation and Yamatokoriyama city (which, incidentally, is famous for goldfish production). Last year’s team event was won by a trio that managed, in just three minutes, to scoop up 173 goldfish! Using paper nets!

It’s all in the wrist

Apparently, for a successful scooping, all you have to do is:

  • ensure the entire poi is wet,
  • keep the poi angled and parallel to the water flow,
  • scoop the fish from its head, and
  • don’t let the fish’s thrashing tail touch, and subsequently tear the fragile paper.

I think this goes firmly into the “easier said than done” basket, myself.

In any case, if you’ve tried kingyo-sukui before and have some tips of your own, share them with us in the comments!


Header image by Riusuke Fukahori, photographed by Dominic

  • Heather Meadows

    Very cool article! I haven’t tried kingyo sukui myself, but someday I’d love to. I have also read a lot about Fukahori’s Goldfish Salvation exhibit, which I really want to see in person…the 3D effect he creates, as well as the story behind his inspiration, intrigue me so much I wrote briefly about him on my blog: http://pixelscribbles.com/2012/01/goldfish-salvation/

  • fee_fi_Fiona

    That’s a neat post! I’ve just realised that salvation (救い) is a homonym for scooping (掬い). Now I wonder if Fukahori consciously (and quite cleverly) chose “Goldfish Salvation” for the wordplay, or if it was just a coincidence.

  • Mescale

    You missed out the true secret of goldfish scooping. A perfect smile, Everyone try your best!

  • Mandarina

    In “kekkon dekinai otoko” the main character gives a perfect lesson about goldfish scooping, but he fails so many times that in the end he simply buys the goldfish XD So yes, it’s surely easier said than done. Very interesting post btw, thank you ^^

  • Hinoema

    I’m kind of odd when it comes to breeding. I don’t like anything that’s bred to look a certain way at the expense of functionality. Goldfish-wise, I’m a koi fan- I love seeing a pondful of koi.

  • http://twitter.com/Kaminix Balthazorous Rex

    Uhm, aren’t koi fishs like…… carp?

  • fee_fi_Fiona

     Thanks, I’m glad you liked it.

  • http://twitter.com/shollum Shollum

     They are carp…

  • http://twitter.com/shollum Shollum

     I’m not sure ‘salvation’ is the word I’d use for traumatizing a fish to death…
    I hope it’s a coincidence.

  • fee_fi_Fiona

    Breeding animals for form over function can be pretty cruel, no doubt about that. It’s not just the final “product” that suffers either – there’s also all the not-good-enough ones that were bred and discarded along the way.

  • http://twitter.com/tokumeiyamada Tokumei Yamada

     Goldfish are carp.