Japan Most Rational Country, Survey Finds

“Mister Spock I can’t understand a word you’re saying.”

Lots of people think of Japan as a very spiritual, traditional culture. To them, Japan is all toriis and haiku and wandering monks. But according to an international survey, Japan is actually one of the most rational, least “traditional” countries out there. Say what?

The World Values Survey (WVS) is an international organization that surveys people all over the world to gauge how different countries and cultures think. WVS hands out surveys to people across the globe asking tons of questions, like how important are things like family, religion, work, and leisure time are to them, and how happy they are.

WVS is super important because governments like to use the results to understand how to deal with other countries’ governments, and academics like to use the WVS to study how people live.

No, the answer isn’t always C.

And for data nerds, the WVS is practically porn. With all the information gathered by the survey, the WVS makes all sorts of graphs and infographics to people to drool over. (Except for design nerds, who will probably shudder at how ugly said graphs and infographics are.)

So what does the WVS tell about the world? The WVS says that countries are different in two main ways:

Survival vs. Self Expression Values

The WVS looks at much people are worried about basic human needs like having enough food and being safe versus how important individualism and self expression are to people. Obviously poorer countries are more security-minded, worrying about things like stable governments, corruption, and food security. Most First World Countries, on the other hand, generally have more stable governments and care more about individual freedoms.

Traditional vs. Secular-Rational Values

Traditional Values are pretty much exactly what you would think they would be, valuing things like religion, traditional family structures and rejecting more modern practices.

Secular-Rational Values are the exact opposite. Countries that are okay with things like gay rights, divorce, and abortion and don’t rely so heavily on traditional social structures.

WVS calculates scores for each of these categories, and even makes spiffy little graphs to visualize what different countries value. Check out this really interesting but kind of confusing graph, mapping the priorities of countries and regions across the world:

As you can see in the graph, Japan is pretty middle-of-the-road when it comes to Survival versus Self Expression Values, meaning that Japan is isn’t too worried about the basics, but isn’t really a society that focuses a lot on individualism.

On the other hand, Japan is on top (#1! #1! #1!) when it comes to Secular-Rational Values. This might not be too surprising given that Japan is pretty hands-off when it comes to issues like abortion, and how Japan tends to try and rationalize its problems instead of turning to a higher power to deal with them.

“Can you guess what I’m smiling about?”

The WVS also measure happiness in different countries around the world. When you see “Happiest Country in the World” headlines, they’re usually referring to WVS results.

Scandinavians are usually on top of these happiness polls, which doesn’t make any sense to me. How can you have all that snow and so little sunshine and be so happy all the time?!

You wouldn’t guess this if you think about Japan’s economy, but Japan ranks pretty highly in terms of happiness, and is even getting happier as time goes on!

Of course, this survey is extremely general and doesn’t mean that every single Japanese person thinks like this. It’s also important to keep in mind that this survey is only updated once every couple of years and doesn’t reflect how people feel about more recent things like the 3/11 earthquake.

Still, it’s an interesting gauge of how the country in general feels.

[hr]

So do you think the World Values Survey did a good job figuring out what Japan is all about, or do you think that it’s totally off the mark? Let us know in the comments.

P.S. What do you think that guy is smiling about? Tell us on Twitter.
P.P.S. Enjoy giant blob graphs? Like us on Facebook.

  • Anonymous

    Interesting, yet I think the idea that traditionalism and rationalism are opposed is flawed. One thing I’ve noticed about Japan is that people there are pretty quick to adopt new technology (once it becomes widespread and available enough), yet many people still observe many religious (or maybe “spiritual” is a better word) and superstitious practices not because of any belief but because it is tradition…

  • Pingback: Japan: Most rational, least traditional country? · Global Voices

  • http://twitter.com/melabonbon Melanie Wilson

    Have these people seen Japanese game shows?

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    dahaha, good point… maybe game shows are as crazy as they are because it allows Japanese people to live vicariously through them. I know I do… haha.

  • Pingback: Japan: Most rational, least traditional country? - Free Online Writing and Publishing

  • Pingback: Japan: Most rational, least traditional country? | Current Affairs

  • Lhachesis

    WTH!!! Portugal is not Latin America

  • Mattias Hermansson

    Sweden is #2! :D Also, who doesn’t love snow? Snow is awesome!*

    * In regulated quantities.

  • John

    Yeah that’s weird – you’d expect them to be included with Catholic Europe.

  • http://www.tofugu.com/ Hashi

    I guess SOMEBODY at the WVS doesn’t know their geography :p

  • http://www.tofugu.com/ Hashi

    I’d definitely agree with you, but to the WVS’s credit, I think no matter how you slice it it’s hard to generalize so broadly about a country.

  • Pingback: Real Need and Real Poverty | Mark Morikawa

  • Juliet

    “And for data nerds, the WVS is practically porn. With all the information gathered by the survey, the WVS makes all sorts of graphs and infographics to people to drool over. (Except for design nerds, who will probably shudder at how ugly said graphs and infographics are.)”

    But what if you’re both a data nerd AND a design nerd? *o*

  • Anonymous

    bad porn xD

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IIHpudeX-Xg 田中キック

    Japanese game shows are a safety mechanism to vent any built up irrationality. It’s a win-win situation, really. People get to watch amusing shows, and nobody goes to work dressed like a banana.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001079326564 Michael Baltazar

    Snow is- no wait… Winter is awesome. 770 times more enjoyable than summer.

    Seriously, I can’t ski during the summer…. =D

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001079326564 Michael Baltazar

    OMG Sweden is very rational AND individualistic? I NEED TO GO THERE someday!

    Sweden is also a great place to ski and snowboard!

  • Jaapie

    i can’t really understand why The Netherlands score so high Self Expression Values .(which is my living place) Just a few examples : (most of  )the netherlands thinks : that woman should just stay in the kitchen, showing any sign of feminine behaviour as a male means your gay, hate for foreigner neighbours(this one counts mostly for old people), just to name a few

  • Pingback: What Japan and Sweden have in common : Karl Andersson

  • RobinWhite

    Do you have any info on how they gage happiness? That would be an interesting read… I mean how do you reconcile the high suicide rate with being high on the happiness scale?

  • http://profiles.google.com/shahiirosan shahiir mizune

    but that doesn’t mean abandoning religion will solve anything

  • Kathrynoh

    How the hell does this survey work?  The Japanese are insanely tied up with tradition.  Maybe not in religion but definitely in areas like business practices.  Keigo = not rational, automatic promotion based on years of service rather than performance = not rational,  working crazy long hours that you don’t need to just to impress your boss = not rational.

    In so many other areas too – like wearing long sleeves in on a hot day because that’s what you do after a certain date… the list could go on forever.

  • http://www.tofugu.com/ Hashi

    True, true.

  • http://www.tofugu.com/ Hashi

    True, true.

  • http://www.tofugu.com/ Hashi

    When I looked at the survey itself, it looks like it just asks people how happy they are and base the score off of that.

  • http://www.tofugu.com/ Hashi

    I’m not sure. It seems like the survey is more a reflection on how people from that country think of themselves instead of an assessment of how the country ACTUALLY behaves.

  • http://www.tofugu.com/ Hashi

    Very true. When writing up this post, I also though of a lot of traditions that the Japanese still hang on to. My only explanation would be that the survey reflects more how a country thinks about itself than how the country actually is.

  • Mark Weber

    Scandinavians are the most happy people in the world because we are socialist contries where we share. This however is not something that I agree with myself(mostly due to this resulting in tax rates at over 65%(for thoose who earn the most) and a VAT of 25%.

  • Maaike Hartjes

    Japan is an exceptional country since it’s both very traditional AND open to new things. That’s because it has a history of choosing to innovate themselves instead of letting things slowly change (the natural way, like most other countries do). Because Japan embraced innovation willingly, they did not have to throw old values out. 
    This just makes me wonder if that scale makes any sense for Japan. 

  • Alessa

    nice to know that gay rights are mentioned in one line with abortion and divorce … -.-

  • Madbeanman

    I think my gender queer (actual term not slander) lecturer summed it up when asked about gay rights in Japan by a gay mate of mine who was going there on work experience.  She said you will find anything in Japan and indeed anything goes in Japan, just as long as its happening over there and not here ie out of view

    And now as I am on work experience in Japan I find that point of view accurate and rational enough i guess.

    However, I would love to know the rationale behind the following :) :
    1 Why have vending machines every 5 meters when drinking on the street is frowned upon.
    2 Why obediently queue on either side of an opening train door to let passengers out yet never ever EVER obey the bicycle or pedestrian lanes.
    3 AKB48- Rationalise please :D

  • http://profiles.google.com/jonadab.theunsightlyone Jonadab the Unsightly One

    > I think the idea that traditionalism and rationalism are opposed is flawed. 
    Indeed.  I mean, sure, for some traditions (like maybe 武士道) defenestrating them as rapidly as possible might be very rational indeed — but not all traditions are like that.  I think every culture has some traditions that are pretty good and some that are pretty lousy.  I would say that a rational society should be able to distinguish between them and keep the good ones.

  • Pingback: Japan Flix

  • http://luckyhill.wordpress.com elisabel

    My former supervisor would often tell me that I was being “too logical” like it was a bad thing, and I think I read somewhere or was told that being 論理的 was bad. SMH

  • Thirdeye

    Addiction to ritual and superstitious practices is a trait of obsessive-compulsive personalities as much as actual adherence to superstitious beliefs.  A disconnect between rational thinking patterns and irrational behavioral tics is quite common among OCs.  I would bet that Japan, and much of east Asia for that matter, would lead the rest of the world on an OC index.

  • Pingback: http://ujani.net » Blog Archive » Links del mes 01

  • Wonkish Rogue

    So a rational, secular view embraces things like abortion and gay marriage. I see. I don’t suppose one could oppose those points of view while being completely rational/secular and considering things like the logical consequences of population decline. Japan might want to consider that while they are busy being all rational and sheet. 

    In addition the issue of supposed Japanese happiness has me wondering about the prevalence of suicide there. Or is it just that the Japanese have violent mood swings from super duper happy down to my girlfriend just dumped me for my ugly cousin that lives in the monastery that recently renounced his vows unhappiness?

  • Wonkish Rogue

    In other words they find complete happiness in their mediocrity while sponging off of the success of those few individualists left. 

  • Wonkish Rogue

    In other words they find complete happiness in their mediocrity while sponging off of the success of those few individualists left. 

  • Bunch_of_sheep

    Woah, someone is a little testy, aren’t they?

    There are many factors to Japan’s population decline, none of which I’m sure is not rampant abortion and every one going gay,  Come on, be honest, that’s silly. nor do I think opposing such will make any significant changes. Usually the main reason for decline is the changing roles of women in society and this goes for any population really. Life for a woman no longer revolves around marriages and children. Women have less children and later (so are men) for various reasons. Such as financial, lack of interest, inconvenience, birth control etc. So it’s rational, not to consider abortion and gay relationships to solve there problem, because it’s not logical to do so. It’s also hard to be secular and be against gay rights, divorce, and abortion because opposition is based mainly in traditional values.

    Suicide in Japan or suicide in general is more complicated than that. Of course the ones that are reporting happiness and ones committing suicide are the same people. Japanese society for a long time didn’t demonized the act of suicide, in fact it pretty romanticized. And life is unpredictable, yeah, one day you’re life can be super-duper happy and the next your girlfriend did leave you for your cousin and your contemplating suicide. Happens to anyone in anywhere. Add that to the fact that you live in a country where, historically and culturally, committing suicide was seen as the only honorable way to keep what’s left of one’s dignity. You may get these results.

  • Bazzy

    well, if unhappy people consistently off themselves, that leaves only the happy ones to fill in the surveys right? anyway, i’m writing a paper on ethnicity in japan, and i got side-tracked (once again). and although i won’t use it in my work, your article made me laugh, thanks for that.

  • http://www.tofugu.com/ Hashi

    Glad you enjoyed my post! Your paper sounds very interesting :)

  • Uloton

    This is alot of BULLSHIT!! only shinto festivals it exist over 50,000 different shinto festivals in Japan and i wonder how many buddhism festivals etc. it does too, they have alot of teples around Japan, food, Culture (Dance, Geisha, Music, houses, architecture, statues, Shrines, etc.) it is what i say THIS FACT IS ONLY A HIGH OF BULLSHIT.. PS. anyway i have friends how live in Japan and they think Japan have ALOT!!!!! of traditions (festivals, houses etc.)

  • Uloton

    Fucking bullshit do you beleave on that joke!!. Japan have ALOT of traditions!!!!!!!! shinto festivals it exist over 50,000 different shinto festivals in
    Japan and i wonder how many buddhism festivals etc. it does too, they
    have alot of teples around Japan, food, Culture (Dance, Geisha, Music,
    houses, architecture, statues, Shrines, etc.) that is what i can say ALOT OF TRADITIONS

  • Uloton

    Fucking bullshit do you beleave on that joke!!. Japan have ALOT of traditions!!!!!!!! shinto festivals it exist over 50,000 different shinto festivals in
    Japan and i wonder how many buddhism festivals etc. it does too, they
    have alot of teples around Japan, food, Culture (Dance, Geisha, Music,
    houses, architecture, statues, Shrines, etc.) that is what i can say ALOT OF TRADITIONS

  • Uloton

    Fucking bullshit do you beleave on that joke!!. Japan have ALOT of traditions!!!!!!!! shinto festivals it exist over 50,000 different shinto festivals in
    Japan and i wonder how many buddhism festivals etc. it does too, they
    have alot of teples around Japan, food, Culture (Dance, Geisha, Music,
    houses, architecture, statues, Shrines, etc.) that is what i can say ALOT OF TRADITIONS

  • Uloton

    You have totaly right the Traditions still left in Japan also the old traditions. this facts is only a high of BULLSHIT!!

  • Fubar

    @5f03fe9fb62d56ebcad58f6f3e5f5ea7:disqus you dumbbell this is only a comparative survey. Meaning that relative to other countries, Japan is a rational/secular society. There’s no such thing as being purely rational, since we have no true idea what things that would entail.

  • Fubar

    @c3d459f0b6e17c8f90e8a7de488ee458:disqus you dumbbell those colorful indicators are just groupings of [the averages of] different regions, not actual geographic overlays. Notice Vietnam is not in South Asia either. There is a general trend for countries of a specific region to cluster together, but obviously it is NOT prescriptive.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Htes-A-Nilley/100000962621374 Htes A Nilley

    Shocking when I first read some of these a little while back. xD

    Much love for Japan and hope they pull through like here in America as well to other falling nations. :D