Why Japanese in Hawaii Weren’t Interned during WWII

Once again, I thought I’d stick with the Hawaii-Japan topic, since i just got back from there (that’s right, eat your hearts out).

In high school, all of us younguns had to do a Senior Report, of sorts. Now, whenever I do essays / reports / etc, and I have the opportunity to write about whatever I want (bad idea, teachers), I like to choose a topic that almost nobody else has studied, so the professor can’t check my facts. I’m not saying that I go around making stuff up, but I feel a little better when I’m not writing on something within the teacher’s field of expertise. It, how should I say, often results in a higher, how should I call it, grade.

Of course, as you can tell by the title, I decided to study Japanese internment. More specifically, how it affected Hawaii.

If you don’t know already, Hawaii’s population includes tons of Japanese. I’m not just talking tourists in khaki shorts with cameras around their necks. Back during the war, Hawaii’s population was 1/3 Japanese. That’s huge. 157,000 Japanese made their home on the islands. In contrast, the United States mainland only had around 126,000 Japanese. 100,000 of those 126,000 were put in internment camps. That’s a lot of people being put away for no reason.

Now, as you probably learned in history class (if you’re an American, at least), “All Japanese were put in internment camps.” That is, at least, what we are led to believe. The history books tend to gloss over Hawaii, though. What happened to people over there?

Well, not that much.

Of the 157,000 Japanese living in Hawaii, only under 2000 of them were put in internment camps. These were people of supposed power, who could “possibly pose a threat to America.” The ironic thing is, though, Japanese-Americans on the mainland posed a much smaller risk compared to their Hawaii counterparts. Over half of the Japanese-Americans on the mainland were born in America and had American citizenship, yet they were the ones to get interned. They were forced to sell their land on the cheap (Japanese owned a lot of California grape growing land, all of which they lost. Sad, yeah?), and lost pretty much everything (My family’s sword was taken. Bastards!).

In Hawaii, however, almost everyone got off scott free. I’m not saying that anyone should have been interned – I think it was a terrible thing – but they should have at least been consistent about it. Really, the Japanese in Hawaii had much closer ties to Japan than those in the mainland. Still, in the end, it was all economy-based. If you suddenly lose 1/3 of your population, then the economy will implode on itself. According to my grandpa, a lot of Japanese ran banks and worked on farms at the time, so suddenly cutting them out of the economic equation would have been disastrous.

That is why Japanese didn’t get interned in Hawaii, even though more Japanese lived in Hawaii than any other part of the US.

Jokes on America, though. I hear stories about my Great Grandma during the war. She would walk around the streets of Nu’uanu, picking up cigarette packaging and pulling out the aluminum linings, then send it back to Japan so they could make weapons and bombs. On top of that, she went around to all her neighbors and friends (who apparently were pro Japanese, as well) and got them to put stitches into hachimaki, which were sent to Japan for kamikaze bombers to wear for good luck. Great job, America! Way to intern the right people.

Though, I would be sad if my Great Grandma was interned, she was just a sweet old lady picking up trash for those dirty cigarette smoking sailors. How nice!

  • fredydb327

    “Farewell To Manzanar” I had to read that in high school. I think. Yeah, I did. Sophomore year. Short sentence. I was still reading books that year. By senior year I did not even read the sparknote. Just listened in class. Thanks to IB, I’m done with English forever. Unless I want to go to graduate school and maybe I’ll need more English then.
    Japanese internment is a very interesting topic and I always wondered about Hawaii but surprisingly never looked it up.

  • http://tofugu.com Tofugu_Erin

    “My family’s sword was taken. Bastards!”

    Do you know who you sound like here? Think about it, haha.

  • MidgarZolom

    “My family’s sword was taken. Bastards!”

    My grandmother gave away the family sword to some movers while my dad was growing up. My grandfather was in the military so they moved around a lot. You know women, she probably thought it was dangerous or something. I always thought it would have been sweet to have that thing.

  • http://tofugu.com Tofugu_Erin

    “You know women”, eh?

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    Hey now, stop taking away my fun

  • http://tofugu.com Tofugu_Erin

    Haha, it sounds just like him.

    Neat-o article, though!

  • http://caitlinomara.com Caitlin

    Did the US government heavily monitor the Japanese population for communications to Japan, or was it as easy as it seems for your great-grandmother to mails supplies back?

  • djarno

    Beware of Grandma Tojo! Do your patriotic duty and dispose of your cigarette boxes properly.

    But, honestly, does a hachimaki really require that much work?

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/CHESTERlikesSUBARU Chester_King

    Two words……..

    Midget submarine.

    .

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    I feel like she must have been doing it before the war was between America and Japan, since there was a good several years for her to do it before communications were (probably) cut off. Though, I could be wrong, maybe they had ways to send things, considering how Japanese the Hawaii population was. That’s a good question, and I don’t know how to answer it :(

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    Well, it requires a thousand stitches for good luck, preferably one from each person, but I doubt she would have been able to pull something like that off.

  • Livvi_Spatula

    “She would walk around the streets of Nu’uanu, picking up cigarette packaging and pulling out the aluminum linings, then send it back to Japan so they could make weapons and bombs.”

    Did a lot of Japanese people actively (for a certain value of active :P ) support Japan during WW2?

  • http://youtube.com/profile?user=chokudori クリス

    I was thinking of the same book when I saw this article in my RSS Feed. Decent book, unfortunately I had to read it twice while in school; once in high school and a second time in my first year of college.

  • http://youtube.com/profile?user=chokudori クリス

    Reading this makes me want to go back to Hawaii and visit the memorial at Pearl Harbor, then maybe stop by the swap meet at Aloha Stadium (^∇^) I need some new shorts.

    To keep this Hawaii x Japanese theme going, how about mentioning the Japanese influence on Hawaiian cuisine, spam musubi anyone? ( ̄ー ̄)ニヤリ~

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    Kinda wrote about that over on koichiben:
    http://www.koichiben.com/2008/07/hawaii-no-oish

    but, i definitely don’t feel qualified to talk about this…maybe erin will, since she’s the one who actually lives there 0_o

  • http://youtube.com/profile?user=chokudori クリス

    Yea, I noticed the article a couple weeks ago, but couldn’t fully comprehend it all because my kanji reading skills still sucks( ̄へ ̄*)but then again, I’ve had my fair share of dining in Hawaii, so I can some-what relate.

    And for the record, Matsumoto’s shave ice is the business, anyone says otherwise, ‘yo mama’. The only thing bad about Matsumoto’s is that the lines can sometimes get long.

  • St

    Well, besides the economic aspect of interning one third of your population, there are four other reason why Japanese-Americans were not put into internment camps
    1. Less anti-Asian sentiment compared to the states on the west coast
    2. No statehood, meaning no outlet for existing anti-Japanese sentiment on the federal level
    3. Hawaii was already under martial law since december 7th 1941, so there was no perceived need for any special meassures.
    4. The persons involved. Delos Emmons, commanding general in Hawaii, seems to have operated on the assumption that Japanese-Americans were loyal citizens. His counterpart on the west coast, general John DeWitt, on the other hand was much more racist, assuming that loyalty was determined by ancestral blood ties, hence that Japanese-Americans were disloyal.

    “Did a lot of Japanese people actively (for a certain value of active :P ) support Japan during WW2?” In all seriousness, there wasn’t a single case of Japanese-Americans sabotaging the US war effort or actively supporting Japan during the entire war.

  • St

    “My family’s sword was taken. Bastards!”

    Oh you mean that’s your family’s swords my family has been using as an oversized toenail clipper for the last half century?

  • emiko

    reminds me of ‘farwell to manzanar’

  • http://otakuinternational.com BZou

    Wow, I never knew about this thing dealing in Hawaii, the history books in school really did skip over this whole chapter. And yeah it was a horrible thing that the Japanese on mainland America was forced to give up their lives just because of some paranoid white folks in government.

  • WOTDsctoo

    That was very informative!

    I think writing about things your teachers (or other people for that matter) don’t know much about is a good idea. In addition to possibly scoring higher, it makes the report seem like it actually has a point. Regurgitation of commonly known things, like reports are usually done, just feels so weightless. More original reports/investigations are more fulfilling!!!

    Anyway, your grandmother was a sneaky one. The sword wielding relatives should have lived with her in Hawaii.

  • C

    St is correct. Not a single American of Japanese ancestry was ever charged with sabotage/treason/etc. Internment was racist bullshat of the highest order. There was never any “military necessity” for it, and the people in charge knew it too.

  • DudeB

    Good job on doing your research. There is a lot of history that public schools do not teach us. In fact, most of the stuff they don’t teach us is all the good stuff. I myself am an Asian-American studies minor and have done a lot of personal research on many Asians Americans and their heritage as well as our history here in America. Good job sir.

  • Fitzy

    Is this the paper you wrote for Mr. Wolf?

  • http://www.tofugu.com koichi

    I don’t think so … I can’t remember which teacher it was, but it was the IB paper we had to do. Maybe this was at the end of middle school and not high school… I think I may have switched parts of my life up, come to think of it…though, I’m pretty sure it was for some IB class, and it was some research thing everyone had to do, which doesn’t sound very middle schooly. Who knows, memory has gone downhill. We old man, we old.

  • Fitzy

    It must have been, since you took off to Japan after that and then you just had regular non-IB classes for the most part when you came back. I think… I just remember making retarded busy work papers in his class and we had to use the CIA factbook all the time >.>

    I also totally thought I would be smarter then I was 10 years ago, but I still have the attention span of a 13 year old sadly… There was a pinnacle I think at around 19, totally lost it now. Good thing I’m going into film, blame everything on the producers and go from there.

  • http://www.tofugu.com Viet

    Hahaha Mr. Wolf. The guy could totally have yakuza street cred if he cut off his broken pinky.

  • http://www.vietamins.com Viet

    Hahaha Mr. Wolf. The guy could totally have yakuza street cred if he cut off his broken pinky.

  • karab1n3r_k90

    i know the reason!
    because the japanese may know the top secret things
    confidential missions and they may know what will the army and the opposing army do…

  • Ana_chan

    Thanks for pointing this out, I'm not sure I like the “you know women” part either.

  • Ana_chan

    I'm no feminist, but I'm not sure I liked the “you know women” part either.

  • Kristen

    Very late, but I am glad you wrote about this! My family was interned during WW2 and such. But I work in a “Nikkei Traditions” gift shop that sells a documentary about why the Japanese Americans in Hawaii were not interned.

    I find it very cool that something like this was posted! There aren't too many people out there who know about it.

  • JackTamaki

    My school has the IB Program too! I'm a senior this year, and my extended essay topic is why internment was handled differently in Hawaii, focusing on the economic factors. I wrote a paper on internment a few years ago in a non-IB class, so this seemed like a natural next step. It's going to be about 14 pages long, but I wonder if I can keep it that short. Hahaha. It's really interesting, so I'm having fun with all of my research. :)

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…

  • krys

    my great grandpa was one of those interned from hawaii…