Putting the “hu” in Tofugu

Fu? Hu.

I recently had a discussion with my friend Max about the nuances of Japanese pronunciation (maybe not so recently; it was when I was back home in Hawaii). One of the more interesting things we talked about was the fact that, in Japanese, there’s no “f” sound. This is a result of the fact that Japanese people don’t fold/bite their bottom lip when pronouncing it; they shape their mouth almost as if they were blowing out a candle (go on, give it a try). So, in Japanese, the “f” in fu (ふ) is pronounced more like an “h”, and the sound becomes hu.

Consequently, Japanese words that have been incorporated into the American vocabulary (such as tofu, futon, or Mt. Fuji) are not really pronounced the way most people think they are. For example, it’s not “tofu”, it’s “tohu”. Of course, when the Japanese word for “bean curd” (とうふ or 豆腐) is romanized, it’s still written as “tofu” because… well, just because. It’s traditional, maybe.

So, why am I telling you this? Well, I had forgotten Max’s and my conversation until today, when I saw this video about college students vandalizing the huge sand dunes in Nagoya:

 

Some people might not understand why a little sand graffiti warranted news coverage in the first place. Well, Koichi tells me that, in Nagoya, these sand dunes are a pretty big deal (he lived there for a year), and my roommate, Atsuko, confirmed this; “It’s a world heritage thing!”

Personally, I didn’t find the “scandal” (the ominous-sounding Ministry of Environment has begun an investigation) as funny as the fact that the hooligans chose the word “HUCK” to scrape out into nearly 50m of sand. While I admit that they could have done this because of their love of classic American literature or especially-absorbent towels, I’m willing to bet that these boys meant to write something a little more… rebellious but, sadly, mistook the “f” for an “h”. Boo foo.

Source: Japan Probe and National Geographic

Edit: Well, shucks. I guess it was their love of classic American literature after all D: A better explanation than the one I provided is here (in Japanese) and here (in English).

  • http://www.vietamins.com Viet

    I see the college students four year vacation are rotting their minds.

  • http://www.vietamins.com Viet

    I see the college students four year vacation are rotting their minds.

  • Onimusha Nosferatu

    my random experience w/ fu/hu… my friend who has fu in her name doesn’t care if you say fu or hu. my sensei who’s japanese gets mad if you say fu. my american sensei corrects us and says fu. wtf. he doesn’t understand when we said hu. my other japanese sensei had me do an experient to see if non-japanese can say hu correctly. even though i say hu and it sounds like hu it’s not hu like a japanese person’s hu. some weird comp. program illustrated this fact. most words sound like hu to me w/ exceptions like shufu. similarly the l/r thing various depending on word too. o the joys of linguistics.

  • Onimusha Nosferatu

    my random experience w/ fu/hu… my friend who has fu in her name doesn’t care if you say fu or hu. my sensei who’s japanese gets mad if you say fu. my american sensei corrects us and says fu. wtf. he doesn’t understand when we said hu. my other japanese sensei had me do an experient to see if non-japanese can say hu correctly. even though i say hu and it sounds like hu it’s not hu like a japanese person’s hu. some weird comp. program illustrated this fact. most words sound like hu to me w/ exceptions like shufu. similarly the l/r thing various depending on word too. o the joys of linguistics.

  • Chimiko

    lol.

  • Chimiko

    lol.

  • http://www.koichiben.com koichi

    what the huck?

  • http://www.koichiben.com koichi

    what the huck?

  • japon

    huck means their group’s name. so it was not incorrect spelling..

  • japon

    huck means their group’s name. so it was not incorrect spelling..

  • http://www.tofugu.com Erin

    Japon:

    I know—I really didn’t do any research (for once). I wrote the article because the video reminded me of what I was talking about with Max; I thought that pronunciation was a good topic to write about, and that the HUCK things was funny (even if I was mistaken). If I offended you, I apologize, though. Anyone who wants to know the real story can read this.

  • http://www.tofugu.com Erin

    Japon:

    I know—I really didn’t do any research (for once). I wrote the article because the video reminded me of what I was talking about with Max; I thought that pronunciation was a good topic to write about, and that the HUCK things was funny (even if I was mistaken). If I offended you, I apologize, though. Anyone who wants to know the real story can read this.

  • Fredy

    I always wondered about this. Haha. Never asked. :D That line with the “classic American literature” got me. Haha. I was like… “Huck… HUCK!!!” Haha. It was alright…

  • Fredy

    The book I mean.

  • Fredy

    I always wondered about this. Haha. Never asked. :D That line with the “classic American literature” got me. Haha. I was like… “Huck… HUCK!!!” Haha. It was alright…

  • Fredy

    The book I mean.

  • Lord Voldemort

    Those sand dunes look so cool! How tall are they? It looks like it’d be fun to climb them.

  • Lord Voldemort

    Those sand dunes look so cool! How tall are they? It looks like it’d be fun to climb them.

  • IAmARAGAMUFFIN!

    XD That’s just too funny! You’d think they’d of planned this out a little better!

  • IAmARAGAMUFFIN!

    XD That’s just too funny! You’d think they’d of planned this out a little better!

  • nick

    i always think of f sound between h and f and r sound beween l and r. the h isnt quite as open as we say it

  • nick

    i always think of f sound between h and f and r sound beween l and r. the h isnt quite as open as we say it

  • Tyler

    There’s no l eithr. Who’s huck?

  • Tyler

    There’s no l eithr. Who’s huck?

  • Kirby

    Ahahaha, that’s so awesome.

  • Kirby

    Ahahaha, that’s so awesome.

  • Kai Carver

    Great story, but a little misleading.

    > I’m willing to bet that these boys meant to write something a little more… rebellious but, sadly, mistook the “f” for an “h”.

    Commenter japon says that’s not quite right, since “Huck” is the student group’s name. You apparently agree, and add:

    > Anyone who wants to know the real story can read this.

    Well ok, but it’s in Japanese.
    http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A
    There is a mention of the “Nagoya large adventure circle “Huckleberry Finn (the huckleberry fin)””
    More in English here: http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/dy/national/20070915TD

    So your post would be just as good and funny and educational, even better, if you corrected your mistake (not everyone reads comments, or Japanese) and gave us the real story behind “HUCK”. Otherwise it plays a little too much to foreigners’ smug sense that the Japanese are too silly to know the difference.

  • Kai Carver

    Great story, but a little misleading.

    > I’m willing to bet that these boys meant to write something a little more… rebellious but, sadly, mistook the “f” for an “h”.

    Commenter japon says that’s not quite right, since “Huck” is the student group’s name. You apparently agree, and add:

    > Anyone who wants to know the real story can read this.

    Well ok, but it’s in Japanese.
    http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.narinari.com%2FNd%2F2007097906.html&langpair=ja%7Cen
    There is a mention of the “Nagoya large adventure circle “Huckleberry Finn (the huckleberry fin)””
    More in English here: http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/dy/national/20070915TDY03003.htm

    So your post would be just as good and funny and educational, even better, if you corrected your mistake (not everyone reads comments, or Japanese) and gave us the real story behind “HUCK”. Otherwise it plays a little too much to foreigners’ smug sense that the Japanese are too silly to know the difference.

  • http://www.tofugu.com Erin

    Kai:

    Let me make it clear that it was never my intention to misrepresent the Nagoya students. Now that I think about it, I don’t even think I listened to the news story very well–on top of that I did no research, so I’m totally in the wrong here.

    I suppose I’ll have to go back and rewrite a bit. Thanks for your feedback!

  • http://www.tofugu.com Erin

    Kai:

    Let me make it clear that it was never my intention to misrepresent the Nagoya students. Now that I think about it, I don’t even think I listened to the news story very well–on top of that I did no research, so I’m totally in the wrong here.

    I suppose I’ll have to go back and rewrite a bit. Thanks for your feedback!

  • Kai Carver

    Perfect Erin! And again, thanks for the phonetics lesson.

  • Kai Carver

    Perfect Erin! And again, thanks for the phonetics lesson.

  • lonna

    ah who really cares all that much what the real story is! I think it’s hilarious!! Face it the Japanese do make simple mistakes like this all the time, so what my Japanese is far from perfect! This was really hilarious!! Keep up the good work!!

  • lonna

    ah who really cares all that much what the real story is! I think it’s hilarious!! Face it the Japanese do make simple mistakes like this all the time, so what my Japanese is far from perfect! This was really hilarious!! Keep up the good work!!

  • http://www.myspace.com/mmx683 Salem

    In that case huck the hucking huckers lol :p

  • http://www.myspace.com/mmx683 Salem

    In that case huck the hucking huckers lol :p

  • Anonymous

    YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!

    ———– http://www.yessoso.com ——

    http://www.yessoso.com We accept pyapal payment. You do not miss it. We need your support and trust!!! free shipping (Jordan wholesale) Dear customers, thank you for your support of our company. Here, there’s good news to tell you: The company recently launched a number of new fashion items! ! Fashionableand welcome everyone to come buy. (Jordan wholesale) http://www.yessoso.com

    The website wholesale for many kinds of fashion shoes, like the nike,jordan,prada, also including the jeans,shirts,bags,hat and the decorations. All thepr oducts are free shipping, and the the price is competitive, and also can accept the pay pal payment.,after the payment, can ship within short time.

    free shipping accept the pay pal

    SOCCER JERSEY 16

    nike sh ox $36

    Christan Audigier bikini $16

    Air jordan(1-24)shoes $36

    Sunglasses Oakey,coach,gucci $16

    Handbags(Coach gucci juicy lv) $33

    Tshirts (Polo ,ed hardy,lacoste) $13

    Jean(True Religion,ed hardy,coogi) $35

    Bikini (Ed hardy,polo) $18